When sourcing slate roofing, the primary indicator of quality is the ASTM C406 standard, which grades slate into S1 (over 75 years), S2 (40-75 years), and S3 (20-40 years) based on water absorption, breaking load, and weather resistance. You must verify the water absorption rate is below 0.25% to prevent freeze-thaw damage. Additionally, check for calcium carbonate content; high levels can lead to 'soft' slate that degrades quickly when exposed to acid rain. Always request a geological test report from the quarry to confirm the mineral composition.